Aquinas's Commentary On The Metaphysics

#48- Emerson’s “The American Scholar”

This week, Scott and Karl discuss Ralph Waldo Emerson’s “The America Scholar.” This address was delivered at Cambridge in 1837, before the Harvard Chapter of the Phi Beta Kappa Society.

According to Emerson, there’s a fundamental challenge American scholars are faced with— what is it they ought to be doing?

Emerson has a reverence for work and the common man. The scholar must realize the importance of action in the life of the American intellectual or risk becoming a mere thinker. Emerson believes you must do action, and the deeds you do become your vocabulary. If you are in your head all the time, you lose touch. Emerson writes, “Instead of Man Thinking, we have the bookworm.”

On the surface, this may appear to be a challenge to what we do at Online Great Books.

However, a big part of what we do is achieved in our seminar discussions. As Scott points out, “the seminar is where you take action on what you read. The seminar is where you start to incorporate the book into the self. The seminar is where you dodge the bullet of potentially becoming a bookworm.”

Tune in to this week’s episode and find out why Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr. declared this speech to be “the declaration of independence of American intellectual life.”

If you are interested in starting your journey with the Great Books, use the discount OGBPODCAST to save 25% on enrollment at Online Great Books.


Don’t miss the limited-time window to get started with Online Great Books immediately!


  1. Michael Shipma


    Love the podcast. So I’m going through some these older episodes and am noticing what may be a trend. Scott will, on several occasions, throw out comments about Calvinists that are not all that positive. Did someone drop him when he was young and explained that it was okay because it was predestined to happen? Have I missed the episode where he processes his feelings about that sliver of the reformational world?

    1. Scott Hambrick

      I’m not positive about Calvinism whatsoever. I don’t have feelings about it, I have thoughts and conclusions. I’m a Thomist and an Aristotelian. I think he’s wrong about nearly everything.

Your email address will not be published.